Going on a Caribbean getaway is like stepping into a dream with unforgettable memories, sun-kissed beaches and tropical islands. Most expensive Caribbean islands will allow visitors to enjoy luxurious retreats in the form of white-sandy beaches, mouthwatering eateries and unlimited fun.
Before exploring Caribbean islands, understanding the unique characteristic of each island is important. Each island offers unique charm, hospitality, gorgeous beauty and everything that you want to experience during your next getaway. Read on!
Best & Most Expensive Caribbean Islands
Not all the Caribbean islands are equal in terms of pricing, amenities, charm and exclusivity. That’s why are going to share 14 most expensive islands to visit in Caribbean right now. Let’s dive into details what Caribbean Island has to offer.
1. Musha Cay
Musha Cay in Bahamas is one of the prettiest islands to visit for families. This island stretches over more than 700 acres where there are unlimited things to do. There’s no better place to enjoy a luxurious retreat in Caribbean Island than a trip to Musha Cay. Island scenic beauty allow visitors to explore surroundings while enjoying tranquility.
Best Time to Visit
- November to June
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $250 per person
2. Virgin Gorda
Looking for most expensive Caribbean islands to live? Virgina Gorda in British Virgin Islands is one of the best options to go for. An ideal piece of haven for those who want to plan exuberant break. From fine dining to exclusive yacht clubs and luxurious villas, there’s a lot for guests here. Even you could make your next romantic getaway memorable in Virgin Gorda.
Best Time to Visit
- During December to May (winter & fall) season.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $330 per person
3. Cayman Islands
Cayman Islands are famous for fine dining, delicious cuisines and beachfront resorts with fabulous views. In short, this is a mixture of 3 words i.e., nature, adventure & fun. Grand Cayman inside the Cayman Islands features grand resorts, beautiful attractions and unparalleled opportunities of scuba diving. Already have everything that any island goer wants.
Best Time to Visit
- November to April
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $325 per person
4. St. Barts
It would be unfair not to mention St. Barts among the list of top 10 most expensive Caribbean islands. Due to its luxurious hotels, pine vistas and high-end activities, it is ranked among top tourist attraction around the world. Also, the European flair, radiant beaches, designer stores and tropical climate makes it best for island getaway experience.
Best Time to Visit
- In winter or November through April.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $303 per person
5. Saint Lucia
Saint Lucia is not only one of the most beautiful islands but also a least expensive Caribbean islands. This island welcome guests with tranquil environment, rich history/ culture, perfect scenery and delicious food. For avid adventurers, St. Lucia offer more fun experiences. Make every moment memorable & amazing by doing unlimited things.
Best Time to Visit
- For more sunshine, mid-December to mid-April is the ideal time.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $211 per person
6. Aruba
For first-timer international travelers, Aruba is one of the Caribbean islands cheapest to most expensive. The Aruba island is home to famous accommodations, gorgeous beaches, delicious foods and more.
Before visiting this island, keep in mind that it is expensive as it’s quite easy to spend a lot of money on lavish amenities or services.
Best Time to Visit
- Mid-January to May is the ideal time.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $325 per person
7. Curaçao
Do you like scuba diving? If yes, luckily this island is best spot for scuba divers. In Curaçao island, no matter whether you are professional or beginner, this island provides scuba diving opportunities for all skill levels. Other than scuba diving, you could enjoy exotic cuisines, vibrant nightlife and picturesque beaches.
Best Time to Visit
- Between December & April.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $330 per person
8. Cayo Espanto
Cayo Espanto is a small island located just 3 miles off the Ambergris coast Caye in Belize. In this island, the luxury villas are located among beautiful palm tress and mangroves. Guests can take a sunset cruise around the island, relax in Caribbean villas & enjoy stunning views of nearby sea. It will be one-of-a-kind experience for every tourist.
Best Time to Visit
- You can go here between January to May.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $340 per person
9. Anguilla
Anguilla is one of the most beautiful Caribbean islands that welcome visitors with crystal clear blue waters and other countless activities. From kayaking and surfing to paddle boarding or swimming, there’s a lot to do in this island for everyone. Also, it is home to different luxury resorts that would make every guest stay memorable.
Best Time to Visit
- Summer time, from May to August.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $150 to $200 per person (budget-friendly option).
10. Barbados
It is located in eastern Caribbean which is famous for white-sandy beaches, amazing culture and crystal-clear waters. In Barbados, the average cost of Caribbean vacation for two is $701.
Barbados is a hidden gem spot for vacation activities goer like surfing, water sports, food, history and culture. Every minute you spend here will turn extra-ordinary.
Best Time to Visit
- Mid-December to mid-April is the right time to visit Barbados.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $376 per person
11. Mustique
Mustique is one of the most exotic Caribbean islands for planning a lavish getaway. The stunning Caribbean allow guests to soak up the unmatched beauty with alongside vegetation and intriguing wildlife. The lavish villas of Mustique along the seafront provides outstanding coastal views with cozy atmosphere.
Best Time to Visit
- You can expect a visit between December to March.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $120 per person in budget-friendly way.
12. Jamaica
A reasonable priced Caribbean escape that is famous for laid-back atmosphere and reggae beats. One notable thing about Jamaica is that you could easily choose between inexpensive resorts, accommodations and food scenes. Seven Mile Beach, Dunn’s River Falls and Ocho Rios is some of the famous things to do here.
Best Time to Visit
- You can expect a visit between December to mid-April.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $127 per person in budget-friendly way.
13. Grenada
A beautiful Caribbean Island loved for its famous coastal towns, scenic landscapes and famous beaches. Also, it features high-end designer shops, historical landmarks and relaxing atmosphere. Make your stay memorable at one-of-a luxurious hotels named as Royalton and Autograph Collection All-inclusive resort. It is located on Magazine beach.
Best Time to Visit
- June to November when temperatures are milder.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $296 per person in budget-friendly way.
14. Bermuda
As per one Numbeo survey report, Bermuda comes with one of the highest costs of living countries. Despite its higher cost of living, Bermuda is truly a unique Caribbean Island to visit & live. Pink sand beaches, golf courses and luxury resorts make it popular among beach goers. Accommodation costs can be quite high during peak season so keep in mind earlier.
Best Time to Visit
- March or April is the ideal time to go.
Average Daily Cost Per Day
- $306 per day
Final Thoughts!
Some people want to enjoy luxurious experiences as they could easily afford travel expenses and we know you are one of them. Just like expensive options, we also added some cheapest places ones in case if you would get low on budget.
We hope that after reading all about most expensive Caribbean islands, you can plan your Caribbean itinerary in the best possible way. From Musha Cay to Mustique and Jamaica, these Caribbean islands are perfect mixture of fun, nature and adventure.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What’s the most expensive island in the Caribbean to visit?
There are various expensive islands in the Caribbean to visit but Saint Barthelemy is one of the expensive among all.
2. What is the wealthiest Caribbean Island?
In terms of GDP per capital, Bermuda is the wealthiest Caribbean Island. Also, it is marked as one of the richest countries.
3. What is the most expensive part of the Caribbean?
In Cayman Islands, the cost of living is higher and considered as expensive part of the Caribbean. If you really want to enjoy expensive experience, go here.
4. Which Caribbean island is the cheapest?
These Caribbean islands are cheapest:
Barbados
Aruba
Jamaica
Curacao
Saint Lucia
